Conservation Bonita, Inc.

 
 

    As a nonprofit land trust, the mission of Conservation Bonita is to acquire or facilitate the acquisition of sensitive lands to protect water resources, wildlife habitat, heritage landscapes and provide natural areas for resource based recreation.

   

 

Preserving land for people!

An investment that pays:

Land conservation attracts economic activity and saves taxpayers money in the long run. Preservation lands saves government services and infrastructure. Compared to national norms and other Florida cities, Bonita Springs is deficit in hundreds of acres of public open space and greenways. The issue is not only the quantity of acreage, it is also about the quality of land. Much of our environmentally important land is planned for development which will impact our wildlife, groundwater resources, and the waters of our river and estuaries.

Traditional funding sources for public purchase of conservation lands in Bonita Springs are shrinking. Conservation Bonita will allow the opportunity to leverage funds with both government and non-governmental agencies. Protecting land with conservation easements and gathering funding from multiple sources provides for a greater chance of success in preserving our community’s natural resources.

The time for action is now! We can and must do better for future generations and keep Bonita Springs a great place to live.

Please help and contact us to inquire about conservation easements or to send your donation, be it large or small.


A conservation easement is a voluntary legal agreement between a landowner and a government agency or qualified conservation organization that restricts specific uses or development on the land. This is a landowner’s way to protect the land for now and in the future. One of the significant benefits of a conservation easement is the protection of wildlife habitats, natural lands, and resources for generations to come.

The seller of a conservation easement is a landowner who desired to restrict development or land use through this option, but still holds on to ownership of the land.

The buyer or recipient of a conservation easement is typically a government conservation program or a private conservation organization. While the landowner seller has specific benefits that make a conservation easement desirable, the buyer or recipient too reaps benefits from this type of transaction.

A conservation easement is a viable solution for landowners who want to protect their land from development. Simply put, a conservation easement is a restriction on the use of property owned by an individual, similar to a deed restriction. It is recorded in public records and generally is in perpetuity. Landowners who sell conservation easements can control the ownership of the property, while receiving money for the easement. The government receives assurance that valuable land will be protected from future development.

What are the specific benefits to the landowner? Below is a list of eight of the general benefits for considering a conservation easement:
• The landowner maintains control and ownership of the property.
• Each conservation easement is individually structured to meet the needs of the landowner, along with the conservation criteria, and can be structured broadly or specifically.
• The landowner keeps the land and receives payment for the appreciated value caused by development pressure.
• The landowner assures the property is protected for future generations
• The landowner continues to receive income from his/her land.
• The property may be sold and the restriction travels with the property.
• Future generations are assisted in the transfer of the land by favorable estate tax treatment.
• Landowners may gain income tax advantages.

Most landowners are interested in tax advantages when considering a conservation easement. Landowners may receive income tax advantages that include gifting, tax deferred exchanges, and gains used against the basis value. Tax advantages can also assist in the transfer of property from generation to generation and can lower estate taxes for heirs by maintaining the agricultural classification of the land.

A generational transfer may benefit a landowner by lowering the value of the property for estate tax purposes. This happens because after the rights to develop it are sold, the highest and best use of the land is usually agricultural.

Gifting is a using the conservation easement as a donation to the government or to a qualified conservation organization. Gifting is treated as a charitable contribution and results in lower Federal income tax.

A Tax-deferred Exchange is an option allowed by the IRS for landowners who owe capital gains taxes because of the sale of property. This defers paying the tax by purchasing another piece of property instead of paying the tax. Known by several terms, a tax-deferred exchange is often referred to as a Like-kind Exchange or a 1031 Exchange.

The IRS allows a tax exchange for owners who have a capital gain because of the sale of a conservation easement. In my award-winning booklet, “We Create Solutions for Landowners: A Primer on Conservation Easements,” see case study #1 for an example of how this might work for you.

Gains Used Against Basis includes basis as the amount you paid for the property, plus the value of any capital improvements, less any depreciation claimed. If you sell a conservation easement, the IRS will allow you to reduce your basis by the amount of the conservation easement, which may result in you not paying any capital gains taxes.

To take advantage of a Federal income tax deduction, a conservation easement must be perpetual and given to a specific division of the government or a qualified conservation organization. Annually, the division or organization monitors the property to assure that the easement is not being violated.

Five Benefits to Buyers or Recipients of Conservation Easements
•    The buyer or recipient can protect more land resources with fewer dollars by buying rights to the land and not the land itself.
•    The buyer or recipient obtains land by way of the conservation easement that might otherwise be unavailable (for example, the landowner isn’t selling the land outright, but is interested in a conservation easement).
•    The land continues to provide economic activity.
•    The land stays on the tax roll.

Conservation easements benefit all involved. The landowner controls the land, the conservation buyer or recipient is assured that the land will not be developed, and often, the public is the greatest benefactor through preserved recreation areas and enjoyment of natural lands.

Tax Benefits of Conservation Easements


Reference: Byers, Elizabeth and Karin Marchetti Ponte. The Conservation Easement Handbook, Second Edition, revised, and expanded. Washington DC: Land Trust Alliance and The Trust for Public Land, 2005. Land Trust Alliance website: www.lta.org. All information  was excerpted from this book.


Federal Income Tax Benefits

The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) treats gifts of conservation easements in the same manner that it treats other gifts of land to qualified recipients – taxpayers can deduct the present value of their easement gifts as charitable deductions from income. 


The value of a donated conservation easement for tax purposes generally equals the difference between the

property’s value before and immediately after the easement is granted. This difference is, in effect, the market

value of the property rights the landowner extinguishes, and is the same whether the easement is donated or sold. If a landowner wishes to claim this amount as a charitable contribution, the valuation must be determined by an appraisal prepared by a qualified appraiser and commissioned by the landowner.


A landowner need not donate the entire easement value. In order to achieve a mix of tax benefits and cash, the

easement may be sold for an amount less than the fair market (appraised) value. Then the difference between the easement’s appraised value and the sale price is considered a donation. A part donation and part sale is called a bargain sale.


The level of income tax benefit that accrues to an easement donor depends on numerous variables, including the donor’s income, the size of the gift in relation to the donor’s income and the amount of other deductions claimed. Accordingly, the landowner must determine not only the value of the donation but also how the donation will impact his or her tax liability.


Also, a landowner can elect to deduct the easement gift more quickly, at a rate of 50 to 100% percent of adjusted gross income per year, if the easement value claimed is equivalent to the tax basis (usually, cost) of the gift. The tax basis excludes any appreciation in value.


On August 17, 2006 the President signed the Pension Protection Act which increased the tax benefits of protecting your land by donating a voluntary conservation agreement. These new incentives make it easier for average Americans, including working family farmers and ranchers, to donate land. The legislation allows:


• A conservation agreement donor to deduct up to 50% of their adjusted gross income in any year; 

• Qualifying farmers and ranchers to deduct up to 100% of their adjusted gross income; and 

• Donors to take deductions for their contribution over as many as 16 years.


These changes allow many modest income landowners to deduct much more than they could under the old rules, bringing increased fairness to the tax code.


Federal Tax Code Requirements for Easement Donations**

Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 170(h) is the federal law that sets forth the requirements a conservation

easement must meet to qualify for federal income and estate tax deductions. The legal term for easement gifts that meet the 170(h) standards is qualified conservation contributions. The statute outlines three basic tests an easement donation must meet to be considered a qualified conservation contribution. It must be:

• A qualified real property interest (a conservation easement must be perpetual)

• Granted to a qualified organization (a government agency or public charity with conservation goals)

• Granted exclusively for conservation purposes (it must meet at least one of the following four purposes):

1) Provides outdoor recreation or educational use for the general public.

2) Protects a relatively natural habitat of fish, wildlife, or plants, or a similar ecosystem.

3) Preserves open space (including farmland and forest land) where such preservation:

(a) Provides scenic enjoyment for the general public, or is pursuant to a clearly delineated federal, state, or local government conservation policy, and (b) Yields significant public benefit.

4) Preserves a historically important land area or a certified historic structure.


**Excerpted and condensed from the Land Trust Alliance’s Standards and Practices Guidebook: An Operating Manual for Land Trusts (Washington, DC, 1997).


Section 1.170A-14 of the Treasury Regulations defines each of the basic terms outlined in IRC Section 170(h). These detailed requirements explain the crucial elements of deductible conservation easement gifts. (CTF can provide you with a copy of the regulations, if requested.)


Gift Tax Savings

Easements also can reduce or eliminate gift tax on gifts of property made during a property owner’s lifetime. For example, a landowner who wants to give land to his or her children must carefully structure the gift over time, or possibly face a substantial gift tax on the transfer. In 2003, an individual could give up to $11,000 in land value or cash per year ($22,000 for a married couple) to an unlimited number of people without incurring gift taxes, and up to $1 million could be gifted during a lifetime without incurring gift taxes. By granting an easement to a qualified organization before making the gift, the landowner may reduce the value of the land so that the gift tax is substantially less or even eliminated, and it may allow the annual partial gifts to be completed more quickly.


Tax Savings on Easement Sales

A gain on a sale of a conservation easement is the difference between the amount realized on the sale (less any costs directly related to the sale) and the seller’s cost basis in the easement. In one case involving the purchase of an easement for its full market value, IRS Revenue Ruling 77-414 (1997) allowed the entire basis of the land (excluding the basis allocated to improvements), up to the amount of the sale proceeds, to be allocated to the easement sale. This revenue ruling reduced the capital gains tax on an easement sale, creating more favorable tax circumstances for easement sales. Advisors disagree on whether to rely on this revenue ruling for determining the level of tax savings, so landowners should seek professional tax counsel.


Estate Tax Benefits

When land passes from one generation to the next, heirs can be faced with enormous tax bills. For example,

although a family may want to continue ranching on its 500 acres of mountain pasture, the estate taxes due when the land passes to the heirs are based on the property’s “highest and best (economic) use,” which may be 50 ten-acre lots. The amount of the estate tax could be high enough so the heirs would have no choice but to sell the property to pay it.


The estate tax is levied on the total value of an individual’s nonexempt transfers of wealth, based on the market value at the time of death, and is generally due within nine months of the death. The taxes have been levied at rates as high as 55 percent, although the Economic Growth and Tax Relief Reconciliation Act of 2001 progressively phases out estate taxes through 2010. The legislation also revised the amount of an estate’s value that is exempt from estate taxes to increase every year from $1 million in 2002 to $3.5 million in 2009. The estate tax rate decreases during this period from a maximum of 50 percent in 2002 to a top rate of 45 percent in 2009. The pre- 2001 estate tax is slated to be reinstated in 2011 with a $1 million exemption and a top tax rate of 55 percent, but Congress could change this outcome. Although a taxpayer may be able to transfer highly valued land to heirs without being subject to estate or gift taxes – because of the exemption – a family with a sizable or appreciated property may still gain a significant tax advantage from the reduction in value due to a conservation easement.


By donating an easement during his or her lifetime, the owner may realize the income tax savings of a charitable gift and lower estate taxes for the heirs. Alternatively, a landowner may choose to donate an easement upon his or her death by specifying in his or her will that an easement gift be made. The terms of the easement and the designated recipient are spelled out in the will, and IRC Section 2055(f) allows the value of a donated qualifying easement to be deducted from the taxable value of the estate. If the easement is not donated during the owner’s lifetime, of course,

the owner recaps no income tax benefits. Even if an easement donation is not part of the landowner’s will, an

executor (with the consent of the heirs, in most states) or heirs can donate a post-mortem easement. Although the future of estate taxes is uncertain, conservation easements will continue to play an important role as an estate planning tool.


IRC Section 2031(c): Additional Estate Tax Benefits 

In 1997, Congress passed the Taxpayer Relief Act, which added IRC Section 2031(c) – “Estate Tax with Respect to Land Subject to a Qualified Conservation Easement.” Under IRC Section 2031(c), if land is subject to a qualifying conservation easement, one that meets the requirements of IRC Section 170(h) and meets the additional requirements (see below), an additional 40 percent of the land’s restricted value can be excluded from estate tax, up to $500,000. IRC Section 2031(c) must now be taken into account for every new easement that is drafted – even recorded easements should be reviewed to check for IRC Section 2031(c) eligibility. This provision does not apply to easements on certified historic structures, although such properties may benefit from its use if the easement serves one of the other conservation purposes.


There is still no case law on IRC Section 2031(c), and Treasury Regulations have not been written as of the time of this publication. Because the law has many complexities, a landowner and holder should consult an experienced estate planning attorney. These are some of the key conditions an easement must meet: 

• The land must have been owned by the decedent or a member of the decedent’s family for at least three years prior to the decedent’s death.

• The easement must have been donated by the decedent, a member of the decedent’s family, executor of the decedent’s estate, or certain trustees.

• The easement must prohibit all but “de minimis” (minimal) commercial recreational use of the land.

• The easement must reduce the value of the land by at least 30 percent or the applicable exclusion will be reduced.


Post-mortem Easement Donations

The IRC Section 2031(c) provision was clarified and amended under the IRS Restructuring and Reform Act of 1998 (IRC Section 2031[c][9]) to also allow an estate tax charitable deduction for the gift of a qualified conservation easement made after the death of a decedent and before the decedent’s estate tax return is filed. This is known as a post-mortem easement. The provision that allows post-mortem easements to be deductible from estate taxes is especially valuable when a landowner dies before finalizing a conservation easement, or before following through on the intent to grant a conservation easement or include an easement in his or her will.


Even though the post-mortem provision allows heirs to place an easement on the property after the decedent’s death, it is best for landowners to donate conservation easements during their lifetime, or in their wills, when there is adequate time to work through the easement provisions. If an easement is crafted during the landowner’s lifetime, the owner is able to make decisions about how the lands’ conservation resources will be protected, and can also benefit from income tax reductions. Also, the holder usually has more certainty that the easement will be granted if it works with the landowner instead of the heirs. State law determines whether estate executors have the authority to grant a post-mortem conservation easement. While the law can of course vary from state to state, it now appears that post-mortem easements are possible in every state. Landowners should check with experienced advisors.


Property Tax Reductions

Property taxes are based on the assessed value of the property and the local tax rate. Property assessment is

governed by state law and determined at the local level. In most states, property assessment is based on the value of the land at its “highest and best use,” which usually is its development potential. Because an easement's restrictions may remove most, if not all, of a property’s development potential, it seems logical that – in states following the “highest and best use” approach – granting an easement should reduce the property’s assessment, and thus the landowner’s property taxes. However, it is not that simple. Applying for a property assessment reduction is the taxpayer’s responsibility.


*This is for information purposes only and is not intended to serve as tax advice. Conservation Bonita makes no warranty on the amount or whether a tax-deduction would be granted and we encourage you to discuss any donation with your tax advisor. Federal 501c3 tax status is currently pending.


For questions and to participate, please call:

Scott Legg at 239-989-4862

Cullum Hasty at 239-287-2634

Charlie Strader at 239-992-6133


HOME    WHY JOIN    MEMBERSHIP    INVESTMENT    PRESS    PHOTOS